Florence Court Rejects Bid to Suspend Short-Term Rental Restrictions
Tuscany's TAR refused to freeze Florence's new short-term rental limits, which stay in force pending trial.
On 25 September 2026, Tuscany’s Regional Administrative Court (TAR Toscana) rejected an emergency request to suspend Florence’s tightened short-term rental rules. The rules, adopted by the city council on 4 June 2026, include a halt on new holiday rental listings in the historic center. With the request denied, the restrictions remain in force while the wider legal challenge continues.
What the court decided
The court declined to grant an interim freeze, finding that the operators’ claims of harm were set out in “absolutely generic” terms. Rather than settle the dispute at this stage, the judges ruled that the arguments need to be examined properly at a full merits hearing. Florence’s tourism assessor, Jacopo Vicini, welcomed the decision, describing the rules as the product of thorough studies and analysis.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Ruling date | 25 September 2026 |
| Court | TAR Toscana |
| Underlying rule adopted | 4 June 2026 |
| Outcome | Suspension denied; rules remain in force pending trial |
Why it matters for operators
For operators, the ruling is a meaningful precedent. Italian courts appear willing to let municipal restrictions stand while litigation runs its course, rather than pausing them at the first challenge. That pattern raises the bar for anyone hoping to block a local freeze through the courts, and it could embolden Rome, Venice and Amalfi Coast towns weighing similar measures.
The wider picture
The ruling lands only weeks after Brussels proposed EU-wide legal cover for exactly this kind of local intervention. Taken together, the two developments point to a year in which municipal short-term rental crackdowns are gaining judicial and legislative backing at the same time. Operators planning new supply in Italy’s tourist cities should treat historic-center limits as durable rather than temporary.
| Signal for operators | Takeaway |
|---|---|
| Judicial | Courts are leaving city limits in place pending trial |
| Legislative | EU-level cover for local rules is advancing in Brussels |
| Strategic | Plan around historic-center caps as a lasting constraint |
Sign in to read the full article
Create a free account or sign in to get full access to Scale Wire's reporting, market data, and industry analysis.
About the author
Scale Team
Editorial Team · Scale Rentals Organisation
More from Scale Wire
How a Warmer Europe Is Redrawing the Rental Season
A warmer Europe is cooling the Mediterranean summer and lifting spring, autumn and northern demand.
Italy's Government and Rental Operators Revolt Against the EU's New Short-Term Rental Rules
Rome moves to contest Brussels as FIMAA, AIGAB and FIAIP reject the Affordable Housing Act
Spain Set to Hike Tourist Rental VAT to 21% in Sweeping Housing Decree
The Council of Ministers votes on a royal decree that would tax holiday flats at the full 21% rate and push owners back toward long-term letting.
Abu Dhabi: Is this the next global growth market for Short-Term Rental operators?
Market data, new regulation and real-world insight into Abu Dhabi's rising STR opportunity.